articles

India’s moon landing made history on a relatively small budget

Space-News.io

Aug 23, 2023 • 4 min read

Credit Cards

Loans

Banking

Mortgages

Insurance

Credit Monitoring

Personal Finance

Small Business

Taxes

Help for Low Credit Scores

Investing

SELECT

All Credit Cards

Find the Credit Card for You

Best Credit Cards

Best Rewards Credit Cards

Best Travel Credit Cards

Best 0% APR Credit Cards

Best Balance Transfer Credit Cards

Best Cash Back Credit Cards

Best Credit Card Welcome Bonuses

Best Credit Cards to Build Credit

SELECT

All Loans

Find the Best Personal Loan for You

Best Personal Loans

Best Debt Consolidation Loans

Best Loans to Refinance Credit Card Debt

Best Loans with Fast Funding

Best Small Personal Loans

Best Large Personal Loans

Best Personal Loans to Apply Online

Best Student Loan Refinance

SELECT

All Banking

Find the Savings Account for You

Best High Yield Savings Accounts

Best Big Bank Savings Accounts

Best Big Bank Checking Accounts

Best No Fee Checking Accounts

No Overdraft Fee Checking Accounts

Best Checking Account Bonuses

Best Money Market Accounts

Best CDs

Best Credit Unions

SELECT

All Mortgages

Best Mortgages

Best Mortgages for Small Down Payment

Best Mortgages for No Down Payment

Best Mortgages with No Origination Fee

Best Mortgages for Average Credit Score

Adjustable Rate Mortgages

Affording a Mortgage

SELECT

All Insurance

Best Life Insurance

Best Homeowners Insurance

Best Renters Insurance

Best Car Insurance

Travel Insurance

SELECT

All Credit Monitoring

Best Credit Monitoring Services

Best Identity Theft Protection

How to Boost Your Credit Score

Credit Repair Services

SELECT

All Personal Finance

Best Budgeting Apps

Best Expense Tracker Apps

Best Money Transfer Apps

Best Resale Apps and Sites

Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) Apps

Best Debt Relief

SELECT

All Small Business

Best Small Business Savings Accounts

Best Small Business Checking Accounts

Best Credit Cards for Small Business

Best Small Business Loans

Best Tax Software for Small Business

SELECT

All Taxes

Best Tax Software

Best Tax Software for Small Businesses

Tax Refunds

SELECT

All Help for Low Credit Scores

Best Credit Cards for Bad Credit

Best Personal Loans for Bad Credit

Best Debt Consolidation Loans for Bad Credit

Personal Loans if You Don't Have Credit

Best Credit Cards for Building Credit

Personal Loans for 580 Credit Score or Lower

Personal Loans for 670 Credit Score or Lower

Best Mortgages for Bad Credit

Best Hardship Loans

How to Boost Your Credit Score

SELECT

All Investing

Best IRA Accounts

Best Roth IRA Accounts

Best Investing Apps

Best Free Stock Trading Platforms

Best Robo-Advisors

Index Funds

Mutual Funds

ETFs

Bonds

The list is grim reading: Stuck, failed, missed, failed, failed, stuck, failed, crashed, missed, crashed, crashed.

Those were the fate of the Soviet Union's first 11 attempts before successfully landing a spacecraft on the moon, according to a database compiled by Jonathan McDowell, an astrophysicist at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics who catalogues space missions.

Even in the modern era – with nine lunar landing attempts since 2013 – the track record is still shaky. Before India's success Wednesday, missions by China, India, Israel, Japan and Russia were three for eight in the past decade. McDowell's database gives a look at the monumental challenge undertaken by the 50 attempts to land on the moon so far, with a cheeky scoreboard that reads: Earthlings 23, Gravity 27.

India chocked up its first W against gravity on Wednesday, after the country's Chandrayaan-3 spacecraft safely landed on the lunar surface. The feat makes India the fourth country to successfully land on the moon, and the first to touch down near the lunar south pole.

They should feel very proud of this accomplishment, Jim Bridenstine, who led NASA as administrator from 2018 to 2021, told CNBC.

Sign up here to receive weekly editions of CNBC's Investing in Space newsletter.

Perhaps the most remarkable aspect of India's moon landing is the shoestring budget – by government standards – with which the country achieved the mission. In 2020, the Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO) estimated the Chandrayaan-3 mission would cost about $75 million. The launch was delayed two years, which likely increased the overall mission's cost. ISRO has not responded to CNBC's request for an updated figure on the Chandrayaan-3 mission's cost.

But that rivals even the most low-cost U.S. lunar lander missions in development. NASA in recent years turned to having companies compete for fixed-price contracts to build moon landers, under a program it calls Commercial Lunar Payload Services. The CLPS program has a maximum budget of $2.6 billion over 10 years, with 14 companies vying for mission contracts typically worth upwards of $70 million each.

Overall, NASA's budget dwarfs ISRO's. In 2023, the U.S. agency received $25.4 billion in funding, compared to the Indian agency's budget of about $1.6 billion. Bridenstine emphasized that NASA's much larger budget is a reflection of the different level of capability that the U.S. agency offers, with everything from a continuous astronaut presence in orbit to missions targeting planets, asteroids and more.

As a percentage of gross domestic product, the U.S. spends the most on space – although it's still just 0.28% of GDP. That ranks well ahead of India's 0.04% of GDP spent on space, according to a July report on the global space economy by the Space Foundation.

India should have in its ambitions the desire to invest more and more and develop the capabilities that are more on par with the United States, Bridenstine said.

India is increasingly seen as a top player in space geopolitically. While China succeeded Russia as the most significant rival to U.S. influence and capabilities in space, India may yet take that third spot in the space superpower hierarchy.

I would hope that they use [Chandrayaan-3] as an opportunity to capitalize on the success, Bridenstine said. They've got a big economy and they're going to be able to put money into space exploration.

Costs are going to continue to go down, which is a very positive development for everybody who's interested in space exploration, he added. And costs to get to the moon are going to go down, especially as we have more and more companies doing more and more missions.

Got a confidential news tip? We want to hear from you.

Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about our products and services.

Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes. Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and Market Data and Analysis.

Data also provided by